The Growing Imperative Of Hardware Security Assurance In IP And SoC Design

In an era where technology permeates every aspect of our lives, the semiconductor industry serves as the backbone of innovation. From IoT devices to data centers, every piece of technology relies on integrated circuits (ICs) such as intellectual property (IP) cores and system on chips (SoCs). As these technologies become increasingly pervasive, the importance of hardware security assurance in the design and development of IP and SoCs cannot be overstated. Evolving cyber threats and sophisticated attacks make it essential for vendors to integrate advanced security measures into their workflows.

Market pressures driving demand for enhanced hardware security

The semiconductor market is projected to reach $1 trillion by 2030. At the same time, semiconductor devices and system designs are becoming increasingly complex. With that complexity comes the added difficulty and effort required to conduct thorough security analyses. Additionally, competitive pressure to reduce time-to-market means that vulnerabilities can be more easily overlooked or exploited, making it crucial for the industry to adopt automated security solutions. As more products are deployed in critical systems, from consumer electronics to national infrastructure, the stakes become even higher, underscoring the necessity for robust security measures.

According to the SEMI Electronic Design Market Data (EDMD) report, in 2023, the electronic design automation (EDA), semiconductor IP, and related services market reached $17.1 billion, fueled by the increasing complexity of semiconductor designs and the growing emphasis on security. While the overall EDA market is growing at a 7.4% compound annual growth rate (CAGR), the semiconductor IP segment is expanding at 9.7%, and in comparison, the logic verification tools market alone is surging ahead at 24.2%. Deeper verification processes and tools are needed to not only handle the rising complexity of semiconductor designs, but also to support the growing emphasis on secure-by-design principles to ensure robust and reliable products in an evolving technological, security, and threat landscape. As a result, the market for logic verification tools — a key component of the EDA market — is surging.

The rising cost of cyber threats from data breaches and architectural flaws

The average cost of a data breach is $4.88 million¹, encompassing lost business, regulatory fines, legal fees, and damage to brand reputation. As the semiconductor market grows, the potential financial impact of security breaches due to hardware vulnerabilities also escalates. Companies must invest in robust security measures to mitigate these risks and protect their financial health.

Cyber threats from the exploitation of architectural flaws are another threat. Plundervolt is one example of an architectural flaw that could lead to hardware exploitation. Discovered by ethical hackers, Plundervolt is the name of an attack that exploited voltage fault injection to compromise the security of Intel processors. By manipulating the voltage supplied to the CPU cores, attackers could induce errors in the SGX enclave, allowing them to leak sensitive data or even bypass security protections intended by the enclave. This flaw was particularly concerning because it operated at the hardware level, making traditional software security measures ineffective. The attack leveraged the SoCs’ power management features, specifically dynamic voltage and frequency scaling (DVFS), to achieve its malicious objectives.

Exploiting such a vulnerability could lead to the exposure of sensitive data, such as cryptographic keys and proprietary information, compromising the confidentiality of secure enclaves. This breach could erode trust in an IP or SoC provider’s security features, particularly in environments that rely on using the IP or SoC for protecting critical data. In cloud environments, a successful exploit could result in multi-tenant data breaches, impacting numerous users.

The vulnerability also poses risks to secure applications, potentially leading to manipulated outcomes and decrypted communications. Businesses could face significant financial losses, operational disruptions, and regulatory consequences due to such an attack. It is a stark reminder of how architectural flaws in SoCs can be exploited, leading to severe security breaches that are challenging to mitigate without hardware-level fixes.

Industry believes hardware security assurance is a key priority

A majority of security professionals from a diverse group across industry, defense, government, and academia rate hardware Trojan detection, IP piracy protection, and SoC vulnerability assessment as high priorities. This prioritization reflects the industry’s awareness of the critical importance of security measures in maintaining the integrity and reliability of semiconductor products.

As a result of this awareness, investments in cybersecurity are expected to reach $345.4 billion by 2026, growing at a CAGR of 9.7%². This substantial investment demonstrates the global commitment to enhancing security measures across all industries, including semiconductors, to combat the escalating threat landscape.

New EDA tools and investments needed to combat cyber threats

The adoption of new EDA solutions is essential, despite the initial costs. Costs can range from $100,000 to $1 million per license for general EDA design and verification tools, depending on the complexity and capabilities of the software. Pre-silicon security EDA tools can detect vulnerabilities early in the design phase, significantly reducing the risk of exploitation and the need for costly post-production fixes while enhancing product reliability. Secure-by-design principles ensure that security measures are integrated throughout the development process, rather than added as afterthoughts.

Integrating these new tools also requires investment in training and potential adjustments to existing workflows. However, the improved security and efficiency provided by these tools can offset these initial costs.

While the costs of acquiring advanced EDA tools and deploying them in the workflow is significant, the investment is justified by the long-term benefits of enhanced security and reduced risk of costly breaches. Secure-by-design practices can prevent significant financial losses from security breaches, offering substantial long-term savings. Companies that invest in robust security measures are better positioned to demonstrate market leadership and build customer trust and loyalty, while avoiding the reputational and financial damage associated with breaches.

Conclusion

The semiconductor industry is at a critical juncture where the application of advanced EDA solutions for hardware security is not just beneficial, but essential. The time to act is now.

The increasing sophistication of cyber threats and the financial repercussions of security breaches make it imperative for IP and SoC vendors to adopt advanced EDA security assurance solutions to secure their designs. By investing in cutting-edge EDA tools and prioritizing security from the earliest stages of design, vendors can safeguard their products, maintain market competitiveness, and protect against the ever-evolving landscape of cyber threats.

References

1. IBM Cost of a Data Breach Report 2024
2. KPMG 2024 Global Semiconductor Industry Outlook